Disguise the redundancy with semantic variation, but all your points have been repeatedly addressed. At the risk of BEATING A DEAD HORSE, I'll address them individually so that you'll easily see them:

Quote Originally Posted by rowdy
...objected to inclusion of animal abuse on this board.
Gelding is not animal abuse. It is a procedure practiced daily by ranchers world-over, with it's own specific instructions and tools. If you equate that with abuse, then you must justify your leather belt, your fish dinner, and the murder of millions of microbes you destroy with every inhalation in the abbatoir of your lungs. Would you eat a burger at the slaughterhouse?

1) Fethishism (if that is a word) does not preclude ethics,
A) Is irrelevent to gelding as explained above, and

B) Depends on the fetishist. German cannibal Armin Meiwes' "victim" volunteered to be consumed, to death. What you find distasteful (scat) is another's bread and butter. Where are you ethics on that fetish spectrum? Purely subjective.

2) Reasonable ethics demands that unwilling, non-consensual victims of sexual violence (****, sexual mutilation, etc.) should not be revictimized by this board's distribution of material that documents the violent crime or crimes committed against them (for the sexual pleasure of the users of this board).
Gelding is a lawfully sanctioned procedure, authorized by the government; the video is a documentary of a legal gelding. The tribal captive's penectomy video is a National Geographic type documentation of a ritual occuring naturaly within another group's accepted social parameters. In and of themselves, they are completely separate from your "reasonable ethics."

Both videos are relevent to the thread's topic and belong in this forum, so that people interested in ********** can see the actual event. This does not automatically mean that sexual pleasure is derived from their viewing. However, if one is turned on by watching them, it's none of your business. Unless of course you're trying to force your subjective views down other people's throats, like some fascist.

I'm always amazed at the right-wingnuts that gravitate to this thread. Reminds me of the discourse I had with someone about my own previous post. Fuck it. Keep posting the pictures and videos and quit trying to censor the board. If you want to be around nazi's, you can go to the TBN site where they rip off old ladies for all their savings and promise them god will cure their cancer.